Alright, after the long 26 days I finally have the results (Some of the judges didn't reply to me in time though):
Honorable mentions:
And the winner is....... *drum roll*
Reason:
It follows the theme really well; it's a great song in the first place as well.
It sounds really good. It's very creative and intuitive, using all E notes.
If it weren't for the theme, this might not have won. It was very close with Escape of the Woolen Sock.
It came down to me as a tie breaker for the two and I ended up choosing this one because of how well it fits the theme.
Finally: Great job to everyone that entered. The songs I heard were so great, I wish I could make all of them winners (I know it's cliche, but still).